Best Shower Valves Reviewed

Gary Johnson
Written by
Last update:

Ten years ago, the only alternative to your faucet was a bathtub shower, which was not ideal for maneuvering.

Nowadays, the trend is to install a new bathtub shower rather than replace the original one.

I’ll go through a few of the options available to you.

Sadly, the newest shower valves are often plumbed into the wall using the old copper piping, so you may have to reroute and replace the old one separately.

Check out my shower valves reviews below for some expert advice on the best ones to buy.

NameCategoryProduct
Moen 3510 M-PACT Moentrol Pressure Balancing Shower ValveBest OverallMoen 3510 M-PACT Moentrol Pressure Balancing Shower Valve
hansgrohe iBox Universal Leak Preventing Valve Rough-inBudget Pickhansgrohe iBox Universal Leak Preventing Valve Rough-in
Single Control Pressure Balance Tub and Shower ValveUpgrade PickSingle Control Pressure Balance Tub and Shower Valve

1. Moen 3510 M-PACT Moentrol Pressure Balancing Shower Valve

Our rating: 9 / 10

Moen 3510 M-PACT Moentrol Pressure Balancing Shower Valve

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Award winning technology that offers more powerful, more efficient water delivery
  • Simple and flexible design

The Moen 3510 M-PACT Moentrol pressure balancing shower valve with volume control, 1/2-Inch IPS is a great option in the high-end range, thanks to its impressive technology and performance.

What makes this shower product so unique? It uses Moen’s patented MT3 Technology (M-Pact) to deliver a powerful, efficient shower every time while emitting significantly fewer carbon emissions. The valve can regulate the amount of water at your fingertips and comes with a push-button volume control that allows you to adjust your shower’s water flow to meet your needs.

The Moen 3510 M-PACT Moentrol features an easy to clean diverter, as well as a removable flow control for easy maintenance. You can even reduce and control water flow using your bare hand by simply turning the rotatable sleeve dial with your fingers.

2. Moen 2570 Rough-In Posi-Temp Pressure Balancing Cycling Shower Valve

Our rating: 8 / 10

Moen 2570 Rough-In Posi-Temp Pressure Balancing Cycling Shower Valve

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Very affordable
  • Very easy to install
  • Pressure balancing keeps water pressure consistent
  • Easy to adjust
  • Easy to clean

Cons:

  • Some claim head doesn’t swivel
  • Fairly basic design
  • Slow to allow water to flow through

Tailpiece, Temp Assure, Chrome.

If you’re like most of us, you’re tired of your old, hard-to-use shower valve getting in the way of your daily routine. Many shower valves on the market are too complex – they’re prone to temperature changes, have configuration issues, and are difficult to adjust and clean. There’s also the problem of the tiny water stains caused by hard water in the showers.

The Moen Posi-Temp Balancing Valve resolves most of these problems. It prevents temperature fluctuations by keeping the water temperature at a constant level so you can actually wash off the soap instead of rubbing it across your skin in an attempt to remove it.

3. Moen 2520 Posi-Temp Pressure Balancing Shower Rough-In Valve

Our rating: 8 / 10

Moen 2520 Posi-Temp Pressure Balancing Shower Rough-In Valve

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Introduction of heat balances pressure
  • Up to 80-percent reduction in temperature fluctuations
  • Long lasting, high quality
  • Not as vulnerable to corrosion
  • Great after purchase service

60-Percent Less Leakage than PEX.

If you are tired of people in your house complaining about the cold water that comes out of the shower, this is the one you need. In addition to your usual positive reviews, this shower valve has some excellent features.

This shower head has excellent temperature stability with only fluctuations of 2-degrees. It also features advanced technology that improves flow rates and greatly reduces water temperature fluctuation. The technology is called PTC or positive temperature coefficient.

4. hansgrohe iBox Universal Leak Preventing Valve Rough-in

Our rating: 8 / 10

hansgrohe iBox Universal Leak Preventing Valve Rough-in

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • The ultimate safety valve
  • Pumps out water fast
  • Easily adjustable flow
  • Minimal leak rate

The hansgrohe iBox Universal Leak Preventing Valve not only prevents leaks, it also pumps out water more effectively than other valves. Its universal design works with most shower fixtures and requires only a rough-in valve to replace an old, worn-out model. All you have to do is turn the valve to select your preferred flow options.

Starting with a high flow mode, you can adjust the water control in 10 percent increments up to 90 percent or less, all in the comfort of your shower. When you select the flow, a built-in sensor will ensure the pressure will be consistent. While other brands might not deliver the same level of comfort, this system provides unrivaled control and safety. It also features two anti-scald valves that protect you and your family from burns.

5. Single Control Pressure Balance Tub and Shower Valve

Our rating: 8 / 10

Single Control Pressure Balance Tub and Shower Valve

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Easy to install
  • Adjustable to five different settings
  • Plenty of water pressure and flow
  • Overall good water efficiency
  • Worth the price
  • Completely self-contained

Cons:

  • Won’t fit if your old valve is the same size
  • You need to purchase Qwik-Fit separately to install
  • A bit loud

This pressure balancing tub and shower valve is designed to deliver plenty of water at the perfect temperature every time. Adjustable temperature and pressure controls allow you to customize your showering experience so you’re always satisfied.

This unit is completely self-contained, meaning it doesn’t take up any additional space, and it doesn’t need a separate regulator. The showerhead is also adjustable to five settings allowing you to dial in the perfect experience no matter what time of day you’re showering.

This unit is moderately priced and offers impressive wash results. It’s easy to install and has truly changed the way we take showers. I like this product at a 4.3 out of 5.0 rating.

6. Symmons S-46-1-BODY Temptrol Brass Pressure-Balancing Shower Valve

Our rating: 8 / 10

Symmons S-46-1-BODY Temptrol Brass Pressure-Balancing Shower Valve

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Exceptionally smooth-operating
  • Works with a wide range of water pressures
  • Regularly goes on sale
  • Can be used with any push-button diverter

Cons:

  • Only comes with one adjuster
  • Can be difficult to install
  • Expensive

According to its many rave reviews on sites including Amazon, Target, and Lowe’s, the Symmons S-46-1 is one of the smoothest shower valves available on the market.

The pressure balance feature of this valve makes it ideal for shower heads that shoot out water at different rates. Additionally, you never have to worry about adjusting the water pressure of your shower again since the Temptrol automatically does it for you.

This sink and shower faucet is compatible with a wide range of water pressure – from 30-105 PSI. It also has a flow volume control. This valve comes with a one-year warranty and includes everything you need for an easy at-home installation.

7. American Standard R111 Pressure Balance Rough Valve Body

Our rating: 6 / 10

American Standard R111 Pressure Balance Rough Valve Body

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Chic design
  • Uniquely shaped water outlets
  • Excellent performance
  • A very low price tag

The American Standard R111 pressure balance rough valve body offers excellent performance and has the most ideal water flow settings. It is a great replacement for your old shower valves and will add a chic new look to your bathroom.

This unique design allows for more ways to manipulate water pressure. There are two dials on the valve body, which will allow you to choose between three different water flow setting while the other dial allows you to adjust the water temperature.

The shower head has unique water outlets, designed for water savings. In addition, the valve body has ledges for easy installation of your shower tile, and thanks to American Standard’s Lifetime Limited Warranty, you have the peace of mind in knowing that you can always get replacements if anything happens to your valve.

8. KOHLER K-304-KS-NA Rite-Temp Pressure Balancing Valve

Our rating: 5 / 10

KOHLER K-304-KS-NA Rite-Temp Pressure Balancing Valve

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Sets temperature quickly and accurately
  • Budget friendly
  • Easy to install
  • Can be used with most existing faucets

There aren’t a lot of choices available for customers looking for a pressure balancing shower valve, but the Kohler K-304-KS-NA Rite-Temp Pressure Balancing Valve is a solid pick for those in need of such a product. This valve is easy to install, and it is designed to match the most common faucet models.

The valve is also equipped with a heated and anti-scalding diverter, which is something not all pressure balancing valves come with. Plus, the valves works smoothly and quickly. The only downside to the valve is that it may have trouble matching certain faucet models. In addition, it’s important to note that the valve is not immune to leaking, so users should keep an eye on any sign of leakage.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Who makes the best shower valves?

Budget-friendly models such as Delta Faucet and Moen are the heavy hitters when it comes to budget-friendly models. However, there are also many models from more expensive companies that can also match the quality of these models or top them when it comes to performance. In general, we recommend that you spend a considerable amount of time researching each model so you are aware of the different options available to you. If you are on a budget, then it is important to know what to look for.

Once you have narrowed down your choices, take the time to actually visit your showroom and inspect the faucets in person. Test out the different comfort levels and adjustability options of each model. Take notes about the different maintenance requirements of each model. Next, ask the sales rep to match you with the model that would be the best for you and your family.

What are the best shower brands?

Divero is a German brand that makes a high-end shower system. This company has been around for over 100 years and it is one of the first to offer a pressure-balancing system within a shower. They are also the original inventors of the thermostatic mixer, a system used across the industry today.

One of the primary complaints that people have about the Divero system is that it comes with a hefty price tag: some of the most expensive showers on the market. Those who don't mind paying for quality appreciate the elegance of the Divero and their outstanding customer service and technical support.

What is the best thermostatic shower valve?

A thermostatic shower valve can provide some great comfort features for the home or office. Unlike the standard ball valves that are on most shower heads, a thermostatic valve can allow you to more efficiently regulate the temperature of your shower. There are three common types of valves: manual, cable, and digital. Manual and cable are relatively cheap and simple to install and maintain.

In warm climates, manual valves can provide the same temperature control as expensive digital forms. Digital controls are the ultimate solution to enjoy optimum temperature consistency and the most human-friendly method. The modern electronics automatically regulate the temperature of the water.

Are thermostatic shower valves worth it?

The best way to answer that is to start with the pros and cons of both thermostatic and non-thermostatic valves.

Conclusion

Shower valves are actually critical pieces of plumbing that are used to transfer water from the main supply into the shower. They control the amount of water that gets to the showerhead or the handheld unit so you can have just the right amount of water to give you a good shower. Replacing the shower valves in your home yourself is a cheap DIY job that can save you a lot of money. It’s also a great way to unclog an existing showerhead.

Our Recommendation

NameCategoryProduct
Moen 3510 M-PACT Moentrol Pressure Balancing Shower ValveBest OverallMoen 3510 M-PACT Moentrol Pressure Balancing Shower Valve
hansgrohe iBox Universal Leak Preventing Valve Rough-inBudget Pickhansgrohe iBox Universal Leak Preventing Valve Rough-in
Single Control Pressure Balance Tub and Shower ValveUpgrade PickSingle Control Pressure Balance Tub and Shower Valve